Abortion opposition related to beliefs about fetal pain perception

Editor’s note: It is not pain or how the fetus or baby feels in the womb that prompts people to oppose abortion. It is about life. Opponents believe that a life is a life and no matter how young or how old any human being is, he or she has the right to live. No one should take the right away not even his or her mother!

編者按:促使人們反對流產的不是疼痛,也不是胎兒或嬰兒在子宮中的感覺。 這是關於生命的。 反對者認為,生命就是生命,無論人類多麼年輕或多大年齡,他或她都有生存的權利。 沒有人可以剝奪他的權利,即使他或她的母親也不可以!

News Release 13-May-2021

University of Otago

Research News

A person’s stance on abortion is linked to their, often inaccurate, belief about when a fetus can feel pain, a University of Otago study has found.

Lead author Emma Harcourt, PhD candidate in Otago’s Centre for Science Communication, says misinformation about abortion and pregnancy is common and potentially harmful.

“The current medical consensus is that it is unlikely that fetal pain perception is possible before the 29th or 30th weeks of pregnancy. However, we found that most people believe that the capacity to feel pain develops much earlier and that this was particularly evident in participants with anti-abortion views,” she says.

The study, published in The Australian and New Zealand Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, recruited 374 people living in the United States and used an online questionnaire to assess their beliefs about abortion and the ability of a fetus to perceive pain.

The researchers found anti-choice participants were more likely than pro-choice participants to believe a fetus in utero can perceive pain before the 23rd week of pregnancy and in the first trimester.

Nearly 80 per cent of female participants believe a fetus can perceive pain prior to the third trimester, compared to just 56 per cent of males. This may be due to women being the targets of anti-choice disinformation campaigns, which systematically overstate the pace at which embryos and fetuses develop, Ms Harcourt says.

Interestingly, most Black and Catholic participants, along with those with advanced degrees, think fetal pain is not possible before the third trimester.

“It’s possible that having an accelerated view of fetal development causes people to oppose abortion; however, it is equally possible that having anti-abortion views alters how people perceive a fetus in utero and affects their willingness to engage with information that doesn’t conform with their beliefs. Further research would be needed to determine the directionality of this relationship.”

Ms Harcourt says the COVID-19 pandemic has demonstrated the important role that trust plays in the relationship between patient and practitioner.

“Being able to trust that the information given to us by our doctor is true and accurate is the bare minimum that we should expect from the medical profession. However, two-thirds of women of reproductive age in the United States live in a state that has enacted legislation requiring physicians to misinform their patients about one or more aspects of pregnancy and abortion, either verbally or through written materials provided by their state’s department of health.

“In New Zealand, obstetricians and abortion providers are aware their patients often have also been exposed to false claims about fetal development and the safety of abortion. I hope this research will serve as a reminder that patients may be coming into the consulting room with potentially harmful misconceptions.”


Publication details:

Opposition to abortion related to inaccurate beliefs about fetal pain perception in utero

Emma Harcourt, Jesse Bering, and Joanna Gullam

The Australian and New Zealand Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology

DOI: 10.1111/ajo.13356

$$$ 如果你愿意,你可以在这捐款支持我们。谢谢。$$$
$$$ If you would, you can make a donation here to support us. Thank you. $$$


No Responses

Write a response

19 − five =